The Geauga
County
Courthouse

~ A brief history

 

1811

     
     The first Geauga County Courthouse was built this year; it was a log cabin with a lean-to jail annexed. It was located on the southeast corner of the Chardon Square Park.

1812


     Chardon was established this year, although it was settled in 1808, and named for Peter Chardon Brooks, who owned the land.

1813


     The commissioners felt a regular courthouse was in order, and erected a courthouse located behind the area where Lehman Pharmacy sets.

     Samuel King arrived and built a log structure first floor, and a frame construction second floor. Needless to say, this has been called the King courthouse (Second Courthouse).

1814-18


     Sometime during this period, Geauga County had its first and only legal hanging. A Mr. Wright had stabbed someone at the regular gathering of the State Militia, and was sentenced to hang for it. This event caused quite a furor, and the largest gathering of the time was on hand to witness the event. Mr. Wright's last request was to hear his own funeral sermon; as a consequence, and to honor the request, the procession stopped at the south end of the park for Mr. Wright to listen to the minister give his eulogy. The procession then proceeded halfway to the Gilded Cock Tavern by the old B & O railroad tracks. Mr. Wright's mother's last words to him were said to have been, "keep a stiff upper lip and hang straight as a steelyard."

1824-29


     A third courthouse was erected where Court Street now sets. This Courthouse was made of brick, and housed the offices of all the elected officials except the Prosecutor who worked out of his own private office. This Courthouse had a jail in the basement. The first section of the Courthouse was completed in 1824; the second section in 1829. Added later, in 1845, was a wooden cupola (purchased by subscription) on top of the two-story brick Courthouse. The Sheriff made his residence in the Courthouse; his children who were born there, later bragged about being born in jail.

1868


     On July 24th of this year, during the middle of the night, fire erupted in three different locations on the square -- it was suspected arson. A shift in the wind, from out of the northwest direction to out of the southwest direction, apparently caused the wooden cupola to catch fire; the entire square, with the exception of the Methodist Church (located where the car title bureau is presently) burned.

1869


     A fourth Courthouse was built in the middle of the north park on the square or commons as it was then called; travelers and visitors would allow their horses to roam in the fenced-in area and graze; it was a common area for all the townsfolk. The Courthouse, built on this commons, violated the town plat; no buildings were to be erected on the town commons to obstruct the view of the park through North Street. However, no one appeared to object. The cost of construction was $88,862. The style was Romanesque in the North Italian Mode (Italian Villa).


     The County offices housed in this new Courthouse were as follows: Auditor, Treasurer, Recorder, Common Pleas Court, Probate Court, Clerk of Courts, Surveyor's Office, and the County School Board. There was even vacant office space left over at that time. The Courtroom was spectacular; it was on the second floor, and went all the way to the roof of the third floor. There was a balcony for spectators to watch the proceedings. Town Caucuses were held in the Courthouse for the election of County officials by voice vote.

     The Court itself did not hold sessions in the summertime for the reason that, in a rural area, farmers had to work in the summer A jury was difficult to assemble, so the Court accommodated the populace This practice continued until the end of World War II.

     There was a bell in the tower. High school children got the janitor to take them up for two reasons: one, to see ?Painesville and Lake Erie; two, to hear the bells ring at a distance so close they could not hear themselves think.

     A rope for the bell hung down to the second floor; the bailiff would ring it when court was in session, and the spectators would scurry to watch the show.

     The clock on the tower was purchased by subscription (donation). The janitor had to wind it up every week with a windlass. The weights on the clock were so heavy that when one broke in the l900's, it fell through a floor and ceiling before coming to rest.

     Each of the offices had a woodburning stove. The Courtroom stove was a ground woodburner. A jail cell was maintained in the basement.

1900

     On January 31, a fire broke out in a chimney where it was later discovered that a beam of the Courthouse had been built into the chimney. It took 31 years to catch fire.

     Shortly thereafter, a central heating coal furnace was put in the basement. Coal was shoved in through a window. Oil lamps were replaced by a single electric light bulb in each ;room which burned your eyes if you looked at it. Each light had a grandiose ornamental block walnut wood carving surrounding it.

1930's


     Two chimneys on the east side of the Courthouse were struck by lightning and knocked down. the remainder of the chimneys were then lowered to the roof level.

     The WPA project caused considerable changes in the Courthouse. In order to house the Welfare offices, the Gallery in the Courtroom was taken out. No longer could spectators have the upper view. the Welfare offices comprised the southern portion of the third floor. The WPA workers sanded, varnished, painted, and completely cleaned up the Courthouse.

     The two great steel doors on the front were removed and replaced with the present doors.

1960


     An elevator was put in to allow for a ride to the third floor.

1965


     The dome in the Courtroom was eliminated; the ceiling was lowered to conventional heights, and the Probate Court was moved to the third floor over the old courtroom.

1976


     A second Common Pleas judge was secured for the county as the result of an increase in population and court cases. The two judges shared one courtroom, and occasionally had access to the Probate Courtroom.

     This was also the year the Chardon Park, including the Courthouse, was entered into the National Register of Historical Places. Tours were conducted through the Courthouse during the Maple Festival.

1977


     The Courthouse was completely renovated. All the elected officials not dealing with the courts were moved across Main Street to the Courthouse Annex. Three judges (two Common Pleas and one Probate) presided, the Clerk of Courts, and one Court of Appeals judge remained. A new courtroom was constructed on the first floor, and the building is as you see it today. The cost of renovation was $325,000

1978


     On May 26th at 11:55 a.m., the tower, which had been weakened with age partially because it had been built with soft bricks (sans mortar of today) was rendered into a damaged state by a stroke of lightning. Because of the historical significance of the building, the plans and designs had to be approved by the State Historical Society. In addition, Federal funding funneled through the state Historical Society helped to pay the costs of $I05,000. Chardonians didn't hear the bells for two years, nor did they know the time.


     The Geauga County Courthouse exceeds a century in age. It has served the Geauga County residents well.


     This data was compiled and prepared by Paul A. Newman, Esq. Factual information was supplied by Maude Beech, Mark Sperry, Esq., Keith Douglas, and George Barnum.

February 27, 1981

    Return to Court House